Directors Disappoint by What They Don't Do

FAIR GAME

" Directors Disappoint by What They Don’t Do" By Gretchen Morgenson – Pub. New York Times - May 11, 2013*

Ms. Morgenson:

I'm surprised you didn't include the classic example of ‘Directors Disappointing’ provided by the Board of Directors at Countrywide Financial.

Shouldn't that board have been suspicious of, and more reluctant to approve, Angelo Mozilo's serial changes to his optioned stock liquidation program? Should that board of directors have been less willing to approve and extend the significant corporate 'stock buyback' program, contemporaneous to Mozilo's option sales? And, should that board have recognized it was a buyback program which gave artificial price support to Mozilo's significant sales of his optioned stock? Should the board of directors at Countrywide have been more curious about Countrywide’s mortgage sales (origination) procedures, the risks of mortgage application falsification, and the non-verification of assets and income of mortgage applicants? Should the Countrywide Board of Directors have questioned, and perhaps even requested, the independent audit details for the quality classifications of Countrywide's mortgage investment portfolio. Should the Countrywide Board of Directors have wondered why Stanford Kurland, Angelo Mozilo's heir apparent, abruptly resigned from Countrywide in 2006? (1) An interesting point, Stanford Kurland is a long time friend (and confidant?) of BackRock CEO, Laurence Fink.

It seems Countrywide board members like Kathleen Brown(2) and Henry Cisneros(3) should have had the financial sophistication to be more concerned about what was happening, in general, in the mortgage market, and, in specific, more concerned about what was happening at Countrywide Financial.(4)

Maybe, that board of directors subscribed to former Citibank CEO, Chuck Prince’s business theory. You may recall what Chuck Prince said about the mortgage bubble, ". . . as long as the music is playing, you've got to get up and dance".(5)

But, I think it’s appropriate to ask, should a board of directors be dancing, or should it be calling the tune?

Footnotes:

1. “Kurland left his job as president and chief operating officer of Countrywide in September 2006, just as the housing market began its descent. The previous year, in 2005, he was paid $19.2 million and made an additional $13.7 million by exercising stock options, according to Reuters. See, “Former Countrywide No. 2 Sees Opportunities in Troubled Mortgages” By Matthew Padilla - pub. Orange County Register - June 10, 2008 - at: http://mortgage.ocregister.com/2008/06/10/former-countrywide-no-2-sees-opportunities-in-troubled-mortgages/

Also see: “Inside the Trillionaires’ Club at BlackRock” By Shawn Tully – CNNMoney - August 17, 2009 From “Lesson No 2 When Investments Get Complex, Do Your Homework” at: http://money.cnn.com/2009/08/12/news/companies/blackrock_trillionaires_club.fortune/http://

In late 2006 the company developed a model that put a lower, more realistic number on the incomes subprime borrowers were claiming on their "no doc" loans. The projections were shocking: BlackRock figured that when the loans reset to their new, higher rates in a couple of years, most borrowers would be spending more than half their real incomes on mortgage payments. Foreseeing an avalanche of defaults, BlackRock dumped subprime bonds in early 2007 when the prices were still lofty.

And see, "Those Valley Boys" at: http://www.scribd.com/doc/141134898/Those-Valley-Boys%20http://

2. Kathleen Brown is the sister of, then State of California Attorney General, now California Governor, Jerry Brown. See: Kathleen Brown, Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathleen_Brown

3. Henry Cisneros was the Director of The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) during Clinton's first term as president. In that position he was very instrumental in the implementation of Clinton’s Affordable Housing Initiative which is credited with ‘putting enforcement teeth” into Jimmy Carter’s Community Reinvestment Act. see Henry Cisneros, Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Cisneros

4. “The Tragedy of Countrywide Financial and Angelo Mozilo” By Gary Jacobson pub. Muckety June 28, 2008, at: http://news.muckety.com/2008/06/26/the-tragedy-of-countrywide-financial-and-angelo-mozilo/3712

5. Citigroup Chief Still Bullish on Buy-Outs By Michoyo Nakimoto and David Wighton - pub. Financial Times - July 9,2007. See the quote, at: http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/80e2987a-2e50-11dc-821c-0000779fd2ac.html#axzz2T5N8MHGw

When the music stops, in terms of liquidity, things will be complicated. But as long as the music is playing, you’ve got to get up and dance. We’re still dancing,”

Additional background: Shortly after being inaugurated into his second term as U.S. President, Bill Clinton discusses his Affordable Housing Initiative in a PBS NewsHour interview. “Bill Clinton: Laying the Foundation for The House of Cards”:

Bill Clinton Explains the Origins of Sub-Prime Lending

In a PBS NewsHour interview aired January 21, 1998, the day after President Clinton was inaugurated into his second term of office, President Clinton explains the origins of sub-prime lending.

Bill Clinton: Building the Foundation for The House of Cards
 

The Big Sub-Prime Gamble Godfrey Bloom

Obama Faces Pressure From Left on Housing Regulator

Obama Faces Pressure From Left on Housing Regulator  

 Wall Street Journal - Developments February 7, 2013

By Alan Zibel

Rep. Elijah Cummings (D., Md.) is among lawmakers calling on

President Obama to nominate a permanent director for the FHFA.

When will the White House finally have something to say about President Barack Obama’s pick to run the FHFA?

That question is on the mind of 45 House Democrats. The lawmakers, led by Reps. Elijah Cummings (D., Md.) and John Tierney (D., Mass.), sent a letter on Thursday to President Barack Obama urging him to nominate a director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency–-the federal regulator for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

“We believe your re-election is a prime opportunity to put forth a new candidate who is ready and willing to implement all of Congress’ directives to meet the critical challenges still facing our nation’s housing-finance markets,” the lawmakers wrote.

The agency’s acting director, Edward DeMarco, has been criticized by Democrats on Capitol Hill, administration officials and liberal groups, all of whom have been calling on Mr. Obama to replace Mr. DeMarco.

Representatives for the White House and Mr. DeMarco were not immediately available for comment.

Why all the fuss about a seemingly obscure regulator? The most prominent area of conflict has been the FHFA’s refusal to accept the Obama administration’s offer to subsidize the cost of debt forgiveness for troubled homeowners.

Obama administration officials argued that Fannie and Freddie could actually save money by doing so but Mr. DeMarco said no, arguing that any potential savings would not be large enough to overcome other costs.

As Developments reported in December, the White House has been exploring potential leaders for the agency.

But the matter does not appear to be especially urgent for the administration as it focuses on confirming leaders for cabinet-level agencies such as the Treasury Department.

Another issue is that it may be difficult to find a FHFA nominee who could clear the Senate, where Republicans are likely to be skeptical of any choice: The administration’s first choice to run the FHFA, former North Carolina banking regulator Joseph Smith, withdrew his name more than two years ago in the face of intense Republican opposition.

Many on the left would like Mr. Obama to use a recess appointment to install Mr. DeMarco’s replacement. But that outcome is now highly unlikely, now after a federal court ruled that Mr. Obama’s use of that method to install three members of a federal labor panel was unconstitutional.

An historical observation relating to this pressure from the left on federal housing policy:

 

In November of 2011, at a business roundtable in Mid-town Manhattan a member of the press asked NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg for his thoughts on the Occupy Wall Street Movement (OWS).

He said, “They are blaming the wrong people. Plain and simple, Congress caused the mortgage crisis, not Wall Street”.

Watch as Mayor Bloomberg makes his, Blame Congress Declaration

They Tried It, and It Didn't Work?

On November 5th 2012 (the day before the election) President Obama spoke to a group in Columbus, Ohio.

After hearing an excerpt from the speech I began to wonder if he actually believes what he said, or if he's just rearranging history to suit his goals. I hope you will watch the video at the following hyperlink to its end. I think I ask some relevant questions in the last minute, or so.

Economics professors will tell you that one of the best ways to create jobs, and to stimulate an economy, is support home building. (Think of all the trades, products and services that are required to build and furnish a home.)

But, I've never heard of any economics professor who advocated a long-term policy of providing loans to people who couldn't afford to repay the loans (However, I think some of what are called "Keynesian Economists" seem to favor such policies over as a short term prescription for economic stimulus.)

I’ve come to believe that many of the policies embraced by President Bill Clinton produced great economic results during (and, for awhile after) his administration. But, as those policies and political pressures went to excess, they eventually led to the housing bubble and the financial crisis.

It seems, the financial bubble that burst during the last year of George W. Bush's administration was a long time in the making.

Just a thought . . . .

Who's Sorry Now . . .

Burdened by Old Mortgages, Banks Are Slow to Lend Now By Nick Timiraos Wall Street Journal, pub. October 3, 2012

From the article:
Part of the problem lies in changes in mortgage processing over the past few decades. Fannie and Freddie rolled out automated-underwriting systems in the mid-1990s that allowed lenders to punch borrower data into computer systems in order to receive faster approvals or denials.

The mortgage bust highlighted weaknesses. Fannie and Freddie did few upfront reviews of loans that they purchased; instead, they screened some of those that went bad, forcing banks to buy back any with obvious signs of negligence or fraud.

After the meltdown, the mortgage giants began hiring armies of auditors—called "bounty hunters" by bank executives—to conduct detailed reviews of loan files to spot errors that could justify a put-back.

deja vu